The primary source of antijewish violence is the perennial obsession with converting the jews to christianity. This astonishing exploration of the dark side of christianity follows former priest james carroll on a journey of remembrance and reckoning. He neatly rebuts the notion of constantine s conversion as some sort of divine intervention, seeing it more as a canny political move, shoring up support in rome. Constantine s sword frank talks to writer and former priest james carroll, whose new book, constantine s sword. Enter your mobile number or email address below and well send you a link to download the free kindle app. For example, while the treatment of the 12th through the 16th centuries is endless, he barely touches on the nearly eight hundred years from constantine to the calling for the first. Perhaps carrolls most eyeopening point is to remind us that the nazis were christians. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading constantines sword. Be the first to ask a question about constantines sword. A history 2001 is a book by james carroll, a former priest, which documents the role of the roman catholic church in the long european history of antisemitism. Constantines sword ebook by james carroll 9780547348889. The church and the jews a history ebook written by james carroll. What i did not know at the beginning of this exploration was that the churchs attitude toward jews is so central to everything. James carroll begins constantines sword, a history of catholicisms treatment of jews, with a reflection on the cross made of railroad ties erected at the auschwitz death camp.
Kindle ebooks can be read on any device with the free kindle app. Additional gift options are available when buying one ebook at a time. A history is a book by james carroll, a former priest, which documents the role of the roman catholic church in the long european history of antisemitism. Constantines sword the church and the jews a history ebook by. The book traces the element of antisemitism in the catholic. Constantines sword is a sprawling work of history, theology, and personal confession by james carroll the author of an american requiem, among many others. Michael hallford critiques the james carroll book, constantines sword. First, does paul refer to the decalogue when he speaks of the law in romans as a whole, and in 7.
As a people who have always rejected constantine s innovative decision to legislate sunday worship for god s followers, i believe seventhday adventists should also take a stand against the rest of constantine s innovations. Constantine s sword, at the risk of understatement, is a lengthy book that actually argues little but avers grandly. A symbol of lordship in fact, the two conceptssabbath worship and gods kingshipare inextricably linked. He asks is it possible that the dominant memory of. It stands in a field of weeds that slopes down from the road. Michael hallford critiques the james carroll book, constantine s sword. James carroll finishes where daniel goldhagen and john cornwell left off by looking at historical christian antijudaism that lead to the jewish holocaust. His handling of historical documents, however, is fickle. What was the political and religious significance of constantines conversion to. Carroll and others talked about his book, constantines sword. Download constantines sword ebook free in pdf and epub format. A rare book that combines searing passion with a subject that. A triumph, a tragic tale beautifully tolda welcome throwback to an age when history was a branch of literature.
The church and the jews a history kindle edition by carroll, james. James carroll s constantine s sword, or constantine s sword, is a 2007 historical documentary film on the relationship between the catholic church and jews. A history 2001 is a book by james carroll, a former priest, which documents the role of the roman catholic. Constantines sword is a brave and affecting reckoning with difficult truths that will touch every reader. Read constantines sword online, read in mobile or kindle. Constantines sword is a brave and affecting reckoning with difficult truths that will.
What links here related changes upload file special pages permanent link page. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. Other books include the national book award winning an american requiem. Chicago tribune novelist, cultural critic, and former priest james carroll marries history with memoir as he maps the twothousandyear course of the churchs battle against judaism and faces the crisis of. The church and the jews, explores the role of the catholic church in antisemitism. Constantine s sword critics consensus exceptional research elevates constantine s sword from a talking heads documentary to a resonant and thoughtprovoking expose of the church s dark history. The church and the jews a history on your kindle in under a minute. How did his political exploitation of the christian religion cause a. A readers guide constantines sword by james carroll questions for discussion questions for discussion we hope the following questions will stimulate discussion for reading groups and provide a deeper understanding of constantines sword for every reader. Constantines sword 2008 95 minutes constantines sword at. He argues that jesus and his immediate circle were prac titioners of the mosaic.
Carroll begins his landmark project by describing contemporary catholic remembrances of the holocaust and the church s intolerable legacy of hostility towards jews. John pauls traditionalism is of a piece with piuss alleged antisemitism. Read constantines sword the church and the jews a history by james carroll available from rakuten kobo. Carroll, a national book award winner, is a practicing catholic whose search for the. Like garry wills in papal sin, carroll makes assertions, backs them up when possible with assertions of others who share those assertions, then considers the matter settled.
James carroll is the author of twelve novels, most recently the cloister, and eight works of nonfiction, most recently christ actually. As a people who have always rejected constantines innovative decision to legislate sunday worship for gods followers, i believe seventhday adventists should also take a stand against the rest of constantines innovations. Frank carden and arlene spiller the origins of antisemitism are complex. Constantines vision of the cross as a sword and symbol of power, to the rise of genocidal antisemitism, to modernday wars and conflicts sparked by religious extremism. Constantines sword, at the risk of understatement, is a lengthy book that actually argues little but avers grandly. The church and the jews, a history carroll, james on. Directed and produced by oscarnominated filmmaker oren jacoby, the film is inspired by former priest james p.
He touches down here and there when it suits his purpose. While serving as ambassador to russia in february of 1834, achmet pacha presented tsar nicholas with a number of gifts, including a jewelencrusted sword supposedly taken from constantine xis corpse. A symbol of lordship in fact, the two conceptssabbath worship and god s kingshipare inextricably linked. Feb 17, 2014 constantine s sword is an astonishing exploration of the dark side of christianity, following acclaimed author and former priest james carrol on a journey of rememberance and reckoning. And from constantines sword, designed in the shape of a cross, the fusion of a religion opposed to power with power itself is the core of the corruption of christianity. We listen and breezes from a whole other world begin to whisper. Vatican council and subsequent documents on catholic jewish relations. Still, lapides 1967 book remains the most influential work by a jew on the. Buy constantines sword 1st mariner books ed by james carroll isbn. The church and the jews, by james carroll charles r.
Here is the question a christian must ask, carroll insists. And from constantine s sword, designed in the shape of a cross, the fusion of a religion opposed to power with power itself is the core of the corruption of christianity. James carrolls constantines sword, or constantines sword, is a 2007 historical documentary film on the relationship between the catholic church and jews. He begins by contemplating the controversial cross at auschwitz and then examines catholic jewish hatred beginning with the new testament and proceeding through the early church, constantine s holy roman empire, the crusades, the. Constantine s sword is a sprawling work of history, theology, and personal confession by james carroll the author of an american requiem, among many others. When christians used this secular power to persecute, banish, murder jews, they were betraying not just the essence of the faith of jesus, they were embodying the very power. Then, be cause of constantine and helena, the council of constantinople inserted he was crucified into the primitive text of the creed, and thereafter christs death, already attributed to the jews by those inventive evangelists, now replaced his life as the central fact of christianity. Constantines sword is a powerful and splendidly written rebuttal to arendts thesis. After that, reciting the lords prayer with its confession of the sin of trespass, i thought of gum springs. At its heart, constantines sword is a detective story, as carroll journeys both into his own past where he comes to terms with his fathers role as a three.
The church and the jews to explore the cultural forces that shaped this history to the present time. Carroll, a national book award winner, is a practicing catholic whose search for the truth leads him to confront. Constantines sword, the latest film by oscarnominated documentarian oren jacoby, is an astonishing exploration of the dark side of christianity, following acclaimed author and former priest james carroll on a journey of remembrance and reckoning. Constantines sword frank talks to writer and former priest james carroll, whose new book, constantines sword. Moreover constantine, the roman emperor who converted to christianity, transformed the cross into a sword and christianity got blood on its hands in the crusades and the inquisition. Constantines sword is an astonishing exploration of the dark side of christianity, following acclaimed author and former priest james carrol on a journey of rememberance and reckoning.
Indeed, in the concluding chapter of hitlers pope and throughout papal sin and constantines sword, the parallel comes clear. House of war, which won the first penjohn kenneth galbraith award. Then you can start reading kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, or computer. This acclaimed book by james carroll is available at in several formats for your ereader. From gospel accounts of the death of jesus on the cross, to constantines transformation of the cross into a sword, to the rise of blood libels, scapegoating, and modern antisemitism, carroll reconstructs the dramatic story of the churchs conflict not only with jews but with itself. A highly personalized history of the first 2,000 years of catholicjewish relations retold as a narrative with a beginning, middle, and endat auschwitz. The astonishing exploration of the dark side of christianity follows former priest james carroll on a journey of remembrance and reckoning. Search results for constantines sword james carroll at rakuten. Constantines sword is a slogging journey through the history of the church over the two millennia. James carrolls constantines sword first run features. James carrolls constantines sword, or constantines sword, is a 2007 historical documentary. A rare book that combines searing passion with a subject that has affected all of our lives. These threads of justified christian hatred form a rope, a connecting arch through history that produced the foundation for nazism to exist.
Carroll, a national book award winner and columnist for the boston globe, is a practicing catholic whose search for the truth leads him to confront persecution and violence in the name of god today and in the churchs past. Constantine s sword is a powerful and splendidly written rebuttal to arendt s thesis. The church and the jews by james carroll houghton mifflin company, 2001. We listened to the congregation singing hymns, glimpsing the mens dark suits and ties, the ladies hats, the uplifted brown faces. The church and the jews, a history, published by houghton mifflin. Download for offline reading, highlight, bookmark or take notes while you read constantines sword. Exactly how did the council of nicaea in 325 and the nicaean creed change christians attitudes. Lockwood when john cornwells book, hitlers pope was released, many critics missed the point in the sensationalism surrounding his unfounded claim that pius xii was a silent collaborator in the holocaust. Sign of folly the cross is made of stout beams, an intersection of railroad ties. Perhaps carroll s most eyeopening point is to remind us that the nazis were christians. We tell stories because we love to entertain and hope to edify. James carroll is an awardwinning novelist and journalist, a catholic and a former priest who feels his. Constantines sword critics consensus exceptional research elevates constantines sword from a talking heads documentary to a resonant and thoughtprovoking expose of the churchs dark history.
Constantines holy roman empire, the crusades, the inquisition, the reformation, and finally to hitler. At its heart, constantines sword is a detective story, as carroll journeys both into his own past. James carrolls flawed history comes to the screen 2007 sdg as holy scripture testifies, jerusalem did not recognize the time of her visitation, nor did the jews in large number accept the gospel. Constantine s sword is a brave and affecting reckoning with difficult truths that will touch every reader. Carroll begins his landmark project by describing contemporary catholic remembrances of the holocaust and the churchs intolerable legacy of hostility towards jews. This astonishing exploration of the dark side of christianity follows former priest james carroll on a journey of.
1629 1564 1248 877 317 606 454 12 768 998 621 1470 181 1295 1098 809 1494 1159 1364 542 1302 1232 1459 448 443 1435 310 1365 181 548 1265 435 1392 1045 806 681 1311 1208 1419 619 9 744 176 1013 681 1379 25 1464