The beginning of a new side of rudy and liesel s friendship. She saw an imaginary framed photo seep into the wall a quietsmiled secret. From the beginning of their friendship rudy has wanted liesel to kiss him. The relationship of max and liesel by sharon lu on prezi. However, max vandenburg and liesel meminger went against this abomination during this time and during their friendship max vandenburg gave many things to liesel. Aug 05, 2015 liesel had connections with many people throughout the book thief, but i felt the strongest connection was to hans huberman, also known as her papa. Oct 16, 2014 throughout the book thief, max and liesels friendship is developed amidst war and suffering. She was renowned as the best word shaker of her region because she knew how powerless a person could be without words. The friendship between liesel and max in the last 100 pages that we have read, i must say that the friendship between max and liesel is one of the more important parts of the book. Although the book contains all the hateful ideology that has made him a prisoner in a strangers basement, max replies that it is the best book ever because it saved his life. Oct 26, 2012 the book thief what is the relationship between max and liesel. It examined them with such purpose that people on either side of the book thief noticed and pointed him out.
After hans returns home, bombs fall on liesels street in molching, killing every one of her friends, family, and neighbors. The book thief has struck for the first time the beginning of an illustrious career. Liesel stole books from a grave digger, a bonfire and the mayors wife, ilsa herman. The image shows the joy of both max and liesel and how their friendship.
Book thief critical essay example the book thief essays are academic essays for citation. When we first meet max, he is in a train coming to molching, with a notecard with hans hermans information, who apparently knew max s father in the war. Max vandenburg is a german jew who takes refuge in the hubermanns household in molching germany on himmel heaven street during the events of world war two, developing a close friendship with liesel meminger. Many faces of survival are shown in the book thief.
Friendship and family in the book thief by eva kubler on prezi. Liesel she wants a book because she was earning it, she needs the book to survive reading to max, power of words rudy after being defeated multiple times at hitler youth, he needs to win, rudy wants food and needs it to survive both stealing for survival rudy for food, liesel for power of words and helping max. Max knew that himmel street had been bombed, everyone knew that, what he didnt know was the extent of the damage on liesel, on his little book thief. Another direct example of beauty sprouting from brutality would be when rudy and liesel find the pilot of the enemy dying and rudy places the teddy bear on his shoulder showing some. Even when max is sick and unresponsive, liesel brings him gifts and reads to him. Liesel not only cares about specific people in her life such as hans, rudy, and max, she cares about justice in general, and feels frustrated and angry at the injustices. Once a reluctant soldier during world war i, he is a house painter and accordionist. Liesels purpose contrast liesel s purpose max liesel comparison max is an inspiration max writes stories for liesel has a friend 247 learned from each other max gives liesel courage liesel relates to max both went through similar life look out for each other shows her the real. Liesel, in the act of watching, was already noticing the similarities between this stranger and herself. This scared german girl, liesel, fought and battled to survive in a wartorn society holding her tongue when there was injustice and learning the ro.
The book thief cliffsnotes study guides book summaries. They share nightmares as their first discussion together. That nigh, liesel meminger truly became the book thief. Part 4 of the book thief deals with max s arrival to the hubermanns house and the unlikely friendship he forms with the book thief, liesel. Max opens his eyes twice but both times falls back into his coma. Never thought of the possibility that it could be max. Liesel is the book thief referred to in the title because liesel is fascinated by the power of words. These are lines from, the standover man, max s loving gift to liesel on his birthday. The story of book thief is about liesel meminger and is told by the death, who is haunted by humans. This quote symbolizes max s strong and determined character.
Lets discuss how liesel and max s experiences are really not all that different. The rest of the book is spent explaining these subjects. As a reader of the book thief, the brutality in liesel s life is evident as marley explained above. Get an answer for in the book thief, compare and contrast the lives of liesel and max. The book thief 3 quotes that show liesel s and max s relationship. Max survived his ordeal during wwll and he and leisel remain close friends until. Max vandenburg is a jewish man who hides in liesel s home. The consequence of this is that im always finding humans at their best and worst. This is made evident several times in the novel including when max gives liesel the book, the standover man for her.
Given the circumstances of the time and max s background, they still manage to develop a special bond between the two of them. The book thief was magically brought to life by 20th century fox. The human heart is a line, whereas my own is a circle, and i have the endless ability to be in the right place at the right time. Liesel had connections with many people throughout the book thief, but i felt the strongest connection was to hans huberman, also known as her papa. The book thief why is rudy and liesels friendship a good. Unfortunately max must hide in their basement cellar.
First, in many ways i felt that the book is about liesel s different kind of loves for hans, for rosa, for rudy and max, and for books and living in general. I see their ugly and their beauty, and i wonder how the same thing can be both. Max writes these words in a fable called the word shaker. In the book thief, compare and contrast the lives of. I feel like this part of the book really showed how much max and liesel s friendship has grown. When we first meet max, he is in a train coming to molching, with a notecard with hans hermans information, who apparently knew maxs father in the war. That night signified the beginning of something huge. The hubermanns protect him from the nazi regime by hiding him in their basement under the staircase with a bed of tarpaulin sheets and a wall of paint cans max was born on. Zusak 161 max on the other hand had to go into hiding not seeing daylight in a long time always with a fear that someone would find him and take him away.
Maybe it just didnt strike me at first because of the age difference. She is 9 years old at the beginning of the story, when after the death of her brother she is taken in by the hubermann family. The novel also shows the destruction of literature and writing, as dramatized by the burning of jewish creative and intellectual products in a book burning to commemorate adolph hitlers birthday. Markus zusaks the book thief, set in germany during world war ii, follows young liesel meminger as she struggles with the loss of her mother and brother and must go to live with foster parents, hans and rosa hubermann. Max vandenburg promised that he would never sleep in liesels room again. Liesel back then blocked rudys goal so he threw a snowball in her face. Jun 27, 2015 i made this video because i love the friendship between liesel and max in the book thief. But as her foster family and new friends treat her with kindness and gentleness, she opens herself to the pain of others, while learning to express and transform her own pain.
In this case, though, in my own mind, i have at least four reasons why max and liesel dont get married, and i honestly believe its more romantic that they dont. Sep 03, 2019 during the period of time that he hid in the hubermanns home, max and liesel became friends. The book thief, by mark zusak, is a novel that portrays the struggles of a young german girl living in nazi germany during the third reich. Her soul, like her papas, sat up when death came for her, and as she went she thought of her three children, her grandchildren, her husband, and the many loved ones from her past, especially. The midnight classes continue and eventually hans begins taking liesel to the amper river for afternoon lessons when the weather is nice. Although liesel is nervous meeting max at first, they quickly become good friends. Max vandenburg is a young jewish man who changes the hubermanns lives. The book thief by mark zusak showcases a friendship of two people named rudy and liesel along with how their friendship had matured over the course of time and how it will continue to evolve. Death tells that as liesel looks for max in the parade of jews, max also looks for liesel in the crowd of onlookers. Liesel and max the friendship that develops between liesel and max is touching, heartwrenching, and extremely powerful.
Though it happens slowly, liesel and max do begin to form a friendship as they come to recognize how much they have in common. In his book ma x is a bird, the story is about all the people that have stood over him during his life, ending with liesel watching him sleep, and then the two trading dreams and becoming friends. I do not own any of the movie clips, all rights go to fox and markus zusak. The book thief had struck for the first timethe beginning of an. Grudging respect turned to genuine friendship, and the urge to fight left them. For instance, during liesel s nightmares about her brother, death told us that possibly. No more than a few meters, it was a long walk to the drop sheets and the assortment of paint cans that shielded max vandenburg. Death visits himmel street, but he doesnt take max s struggling soul, and he doesnt see liesel. Sam liesel did not marry max, simply because a, max was too old for her, and b they had form a strong bond of friendship rather than romantic relationship. Also, the biggest thing max has bestowed on liesel is showing her the power of words. I made this video because i love the friendship between liesel and max in the book thief. He writes books about liesel, telling her how her friendship gives him strength during his hiding. The book max wrote liesel is extremely special, and symbolizes their tight bond and relationship.
Hitler used his words to come to power, and get rid of the jewish people. Reading the book thief helped me understand another use of words and friendship during the shoah. Both have left their respective families and have been adopted by the hubermans. When death captures me, the boy vowed, he will feel my fist in his face. Overall, the novel seems to demonstrate the power that words of friendship have to overshadow words of hatred.
Hans hubermann papa liesel s foster father and husband of rosa, hans is a former german soldier during the first world war, accordion player, and painter. Max and liesel max vandenburg and liesel have a lot of similarities in there lifes they both have nightmares about something horrible that happened to them and they still cant heal from that experience. Dec 11, 2015 the story of book thief is about liesel meminger and is told by the death, who is haunted by humans. Although in this story the friendship is more of rudy in love with liesel, but liesel was also filled with a brotherly love. The book thief by markus zusak discussion questions. Liesel sits and talks to max, but he keeps sleeping for days.
A friendship because of circumstances although one might think that nothing good came about because of nazi germany, liesel and max s friendship disproves that. The idea of a jewish male and a german girl becoming good acquaintances is an unimaginable, punishable thought in the time that the book thief is written. The first letter is from rudys heart and it is the true form of how rudy is and how he feels about liesel. He states that the book thief died only yesterday, that she lived a long life in a place far away from munich and himmel street in a suburb of sydney. Max has left his family and liesel has lost her brother. Max recognizes that because liesel had to fight to gain her power over wordsonly learning to read at age tenshe understands their importance better than most people, which in turn gives her more power. She removed the sheets closest to the wall until there was a small corridor to look through. Liesel and max did not have the most auspicious start to their friendship. Through her stealing of books, she helps support her family and friends, and in the process of doing so discovers the horrors and beauty of human nature. Liesel twice asks max if mkpf, which he has by his bedside, is a good book. Liesel did not know how to read until this book and it was a milestone for her to finish her book in what ways is rudys first letter to liesel more appropriate than the second, approved version. The book thief is framed by various other books, not the least of which is protagonist liesel s memoir, the book thief. Aug 31, 2015 the book thief was magically brought to life by 20th century fox.
Death is the sympathetic narrator of liesels story. Not only that, but when he does start to get better, max confides in liesel and tells her that he is scared. He was the one who she knew was there for him when she first arrived to her foster home on himmel street. Finally rosa makes liesel go out and play soccer to take a break. Throughout the book thief, max and liesel s friendship is developed amidst war and suffering. The friendship that develops between liesel and max is touching, heartwrenching, and extremely powerful. Hans hubermann, max vandenburg, and michael holtzapfel. These prophetic words to her, early in the story, foreshadow the end and reflect the literal and figurative meanings of dying. Liesel could feel someone standing over her as she lay in her bed. Get free homework help on markus zusaks the book thief. A friendship because of circumstances although one might think that nothing good came about because of nazi germany, liesel and maxs friendship disproves that. The book thief why is rudy and liesels friendship a.
Although one was a jewish fist fighter and one was a german book thief, max and liesel soon saw that they had things in common. The first part of him she saw was his shoulder, and through the slender gap, she slowly, painfully. Both hans and max illustrate that the guilt of survival can be overcome by going on to live a worthy life, loving others, and making up for any wrongs. Mar 01, 2011 some of the differences about max and liesel are that liesel got away from being treated bad well somewhat. This is made evident several times in the novel including when max gives liesel the book, the standover man for her birthday. It shows how liesels power of words helped max through the concentration camp. The last page is a picture of the basement, with the words painted on the wall next to a framed picture of max the bird embracing liesel.
Given the circumstances of the time and maxs background, they still manage to develop a special bond between the two of them. Liesel and max find themselves living together because of terrible events that have occurred to their families. Although they love each other, first as childhood friends and later as young teenagers, liesel never kisses rudy until the very end, when rudy is dead and liesel, griefstricken, wants very much. Max and liesel s relationship develops and deepens in this chapter. Liesel s strong friendship with max made it so that max wasnt bored by himself in the hubermanns basement. Compare and contrast the lives of liesel and max vandenburg. Dec 15, 2014 the book thief by mark zusak showcases a friendship of two people named rudy and liesel along with how their friendship had matured over the course of time and how it will continue to evolve. Eva kubler, payton johnston, and arman hosseini friendships rudy and liesel started as friendly neighbors but throughout the story became best friends rudy is in love with liesel from the beginning, yet liesel only sees him as a. After the war chapter 1, a book thief fanfic fanfiction. Anyway, when reading the book, and till this day, i think she married rudys older brother, alex. Death says that liesel was a girl with a mountain to climb. Max gives liesel a story called the standover man for her birthday. The relationship between max and liesel is a great marvel in markus zusak s, the book thief, and is a huge turning point in the book as well. When liesel moved to 33 himmelstreet rudy became her next door neighbour.
Liesel loves rosa and hans as mother and father figures. Hans hubermann papa liesels foster father and husband of rosa, hans is a former german soldier during the first world war, accordion player, and painter. The best world shakers were the ones who understood the true power of words. His father protected hans, liesel s foster father, during the first world war, so hans tries to keep max safe from the nazis even though. Perhaps the reason that these two characters gravitate towards each other is because of their incredible similarities. Max vandenburg, a jew hiding from the nazis, gets a small revenge for this by painting over the pages of hitlers own book, mein kampf, and writing stories for liesel over top of them. The strong friendship of max and liesel in the book thief, a. The strong friendship of max and liesel in the book thief. Liesel memingermax vandenburg works archive of our own.
The book thief had struck for the first time the beginning of an illustrious career. He is telling us here the book is about liesel, her books, hans, erik and their shared accordion, the nazis, max eriks son, and the books liesel steals. Inspired by the line the colder he got, the more he melted in the book thief about max vandenburg, and the book thief in general. Max and liesel are alike in many ways, one of which is the reoccurrence of.
489 551 364 63 946 1679 1523 1555 222 301 931 742 99 832 443 92 720 607 494 1420 409 258 409 325 1303 974 727 548 275 258 299 758 1452 381 1069 1148 504 643